Business Valuation Expert Witness: What Attorneys Should Look For
We’ve seen situations where one expert values a privately held business at $3 million and another arrives at $6 million. For the attorney handling the case, the difference raises an immediate question: Which conclusion can be supported, explained and defended?
That is where the experience of a business valuation expert witness matters. A valuation may provide a starting point for negotiation, but counsel also needs an expert who can identify disputed assumptions, respond to an opposing opinion and explain complicated financial issues clearly if the case proceeds to deposition or trial.
At Sun Business Valuations, we work directly with attorneys and their clients in divorce, ownership disputes and other business litigation. We prepare valuations, critique opposing reports and provide business valuation litigation support throughout the case.
When Do Attorneys Need a Business Valuation Expert Witness?
An attorney may need a valuation expert when the value of a privately held business or ownership interest is material to a dispute. Sometimes the parties need a credible valuation to reach a settlement. In contested matters, counsel may also need an expert who is prepared to defend the analysis under questioning.
Common engagements include:
- Divorce and equitable distribution. A business may be one of the largest and most difficult assets to value in a marital estate. A divorce business valuation expert can help counsel understand the value of the ownership interest and the issues likely to be disputed.
- Shareholder and partner disputes. When owners disagree over a buyout or no buy-sell agreement establishes the terms, an independent valuation may support negotiations or litigation. Our work in partnership buyouts and disputes includes helping four shareholders of a media production company reach an amicable buyout without an existing buy-sell agreement.
- Other corporate litigation. Disputes involving ownership interests and business value may require valuation analysis and litigation support, whether the matter settles or proceeds to court.
Many matters settle before trial. Still, an expert’s work should be prepared with scrutiny in mind from the outset. A well-supported opinion can be valuable in mediation and equally important if the assumptions are challenged later.
What Should Attorneys Look for in a Business Valuation Expert Witness?
Technical credentials matter, but they are only part of the decision. Counsel should consider whether the expert has experience with the type of business and dispute, can explain the basis for an opinion and is comfortable defending that opinion.
Relevant valuation and litigation experience
An expert should understand how privately held companies operate and how their financial records can differ from their underlying earning capacity. Litigation experience also matters. An analyst who can prepare a report may not have the same experience answering pointed questions in a deposition or explaining an opinion in court.
At Sun, business valuation is our specialty. Thomas F. Theurkauf, CPA, ABV, ASA, CVA, CFA, brings extensive experience in valuation litigation support, depositions and expert testimony in state and federal courts. Stephen J. Goldberg founded Sun in 1999 and works closely with attorneys and their clients throughout valuation engagements.
An opinion that can withstand scrutiny
Attorneys do not need to master business valuation methodology, but they should know whether the expert can support the important judgments in a report. That includes the financial information relied upon, adjustments to earnings, business risks and the choice of valuation methods.
Before comparing two opinions, counsel should also confirm that the experts evaluated the same ownership interest using the appropriate valuation date and standard of value. In divorce matters, issues such as personal versus enterprise goodwill or discounts related to a minority interest may affect the analysis depending on applicable law.
The important question is whether the expert can explain why an assumption is appropriate and what happens to the conclusion if that assumption changes.
Clear communication with counsel and the court
An expert’s analysis is more useful when attorneys and their clients can understand it. A strong expert can explain complex financial findings in straightforward language, identify the issues that materially affect value and prepare counsel for questions likely to arise from the opposing side.
How a Business Valuation Expert Supports a Case Beyond the Report
A valuation report is one part of the engagement. Attorneys may also need help understanding how the conclusion affects negotiations, evaluating an opposing opinion and preparing for testimony.
Reviewing an opposing expert’s report. We examine source records, adjustments, industry information and key assumptions to identify where the other opinion may lack support. A critique of an opposing expert report can focus on a particular issue or involve a broader written analysis. We can also show how a better-supported input would affect the value conclusion.
Preparing for depositions and cross-examination. Our analysis can help counsel focus questions on the assumptions that matter, rather than simply challenging the opposing expert’s final number.
Supporting settlement and mediation. We explain the findings, discuss points of disagreement and help attorneys understand the financial implications of competing positions. Establishing business value does not automatically determine the cash available to fund a settlement, which may require a separate financial analysis.
Providing expert testimony. When a matter proceeds, we can explain the analysis and respond to questions about the data, methods and professional judgments supporting the conclusion.
A critique of another expert’s report is a separate engagement from a full business valuation. We discuss its scope and quote the fee before beginning.
One Expert or Separate Experts?
Sun works with individual parties and is also jointly retained by both sides in some disputes. The right arrangement depends on the circumstances and the parties’ willingness to follow a shared process.
In a joint engagement, both sides should understand what information will be provided, who participates in the intake conference and how communications and the report will be shared. A transparent process can make the resulting opinion easier for both parties to evaluate.
With separate experts, each party has its own valuation professional. When the conclusions differ, counsel can examine the specific assumptions and judgments behind the gap. In either arrangement, the valuation must be supported by the evidence.
How Sun Business Valuations Works With Attorneys
We understand that attorneys face discovery deadlines, mediation dates and clients who need to know what the work will cost. Our process is designed to make the scope, timeline and findings clear.
We begin with a conversation about the business, the issues in dispute and any deadlines. From there, we provide an information request and hold an intake conference with counsel and the client. That discussion covers the financial records and the operational details needed to understand the company.
We typically provide a draft valuation report within 10 to 15 business days after receiving the requested information and completing the intake conference. Counsel then has an opportunity to review the findings with us, ask questions and discuss the purpose of the engagement before we issue the final report. If a deadline is approaching, we discuss what may be possible.
Our full valuation engagements are quoted at a fixed fee, with the scope and payment terms established in the engagement letter. Follow-up discussions and remote expert testimony are generally included within that scope. Opposing-report critiques are scoped and priced separately. This gives attorneys a clearer basis for discussing costs with their clients.
Frequently Asked Questions
When should an attorney involve a business valuation expert?
Early involvement gives counsel time to identify the valuation date, request the relevant records and address possible disputes before mediation or a court deadline. It also helps define what the expert is being asked to determine.
Can Sun review an opposing valuation without preparing an entirely new report?
Yes. We can undertake a focused critique of an opposing expert’s assumptions, methods or supporting information. The scope depends on the report and the issues counsel wants us to address.
Can Sun help when my client does not have access to the business’s financial records?
Yes. We are accustomed to working with incomplete information, including situations involving a non-owner spouse or minority owner. We help identify the missing records and explain any limitations that affect the analysis.
Can a valuation expert help if the case never goes to trial?
Yes. Many engagements support negotiations and mediation. A clear, well-supported valuation can help the parties understand their positions and work toward a resolution without testimony.
Discuss Your Case With Sun Business Valuations
If a business valuation is part of a matter you are handling, we welcome an initial conversation. We can discuss the case, available information, timeline, and the appropriate scope of work.
Call Stephen Goldberg, Managing Partner, at 800.232.0180, or contact us online to start the conversation.